No stars so lovely: what to write when Edinburgh’s your home town

5 August, 2007 Posted by Joanna As Reflections

CloseWhen I got tagged by Robert Hruzek to write about my home town I thought it would be a relatively easy writing task.  Edinburgh, capital city of Scotland, festival city, historical city, literary city…

But of course, like all writing tasks, the more there is to say the harder it is to find the right words.

On the eve of the Fringe I could have told you about the wild burst of music, art, comedy and drama that hits Edinburgh’s theatres, pubs, clubs and streets for the month of August.  About buskers, hustlers, mime-artists, circus acts bamboozling the crowds on the Royal Mile.  About the hordes of tourists who arrive by the bus-load at this time of year, looking for accommodation, for tickets to the best shows, for hot off the press reviews, for a cool beer in the summer heat or shelter from the rain when the heavens open.

But that’s only part of Edinburgh, of course.

Perhaps I could have told you about the seemier side of the city streets.  The Edinburgh of detective stories and crime novels.  The underworld of Ian Rankin’s Rebus.  The Leith of Irvine Welsh’s Trainspotting.  It’s another part of the city.  Another narrative. An other world: true and complete in itself.  And yet still.  Only part of the story.

Perhaps I could have told you how it is possible to travel through time in Edinburgh.  How you can be walking one moment through warm, sweaty crowds of Australians and Americans, past the tourist shops in the Royal Mile, past the crowds watching the free entertainment, squeeze past the people blocking the pavement and step down, down into a quiet, cool, dank close.  Lose your bearings for a moment and wonder where you are.  Wait for your eyes to adjust to the sudden, sharp contrast of sunlight and cool, damp, dank darkness.  Look about and see you’re alone.  Transported, suddenly, instantly, into a different world, a different atmosphere, a different place, a different time… maybe.

CanalPerhaps I would take you instead to the villages that make up the surrounds of the town.  Tell you what it’s like to wander the streets half an hour’s walk from the city centre.  How I can turn, one way, from the street at the end of my door and be on a busy, dirty, grimy thoroughfare, a road choked with traffic and buses, the pavements strewn with crisp packets and bags of chips.  How I can turn, the other way, and find an oasis.  The calm of the canal, green, calm, peaceful.  Ducks parading for bread.  Rowing boats showing off their reflections in the still water on a sunny day.

And still none of these would tell you the whole story.

Edinburgh is all of these things, and none of them.  It is a city of contrasts: rich and poor, darkness and light, ancient and modern.

It is Hugh MacDiarmid’s “mad god’s dream”.

It is busy, manic, dirty, grimy, touristy, tacky, overwhelming in summer… with a beauty you can’t shake off.  To echo the words of Robert Louis Stevenson:

“I will say it fairly, it grows on me with every year: there are no stars so lovely as Edinburgh street-lamps.”

The home town meme

Struth.  Now I’ve written it I’m not sure I’ve even answered the question… Never mind - I hope you enjoyed reading it anyway!

Here’s the question Robert’s put: What, in your opinion, is or are the most amazing, unusual, strange or just plain weird things about where you live?

Now, all you have to do is write a post answering the above question, then tag a few folks (choose your own number).

Don’t limit yourself to just one thing, either – in fact, the more, the merrier. PLEASE include photos as appropriate (to amaze us all, and, you know, prove you’re not kidding – we all know what a picture is worth, right?), but remember – the more memorable, the better!

Please link back to Robert’s original post so he can pull them all together (so he says - although there’s another group writing project running too…)

Feel free to jump in (and link back) if you want to join in, meantime I’m tagging some regular readers and commenters here:

Laura at Writing Thoughts

Jeanne at Writer’s Notes

Yvonne at Grow Your Writing Business

Brad at Word Sell

Categories : Reflections

Comments
LauraNo Gravatar August 5, 2007

Thanks! I’ll have to think about this one. First, I have to decide which one is my home town. I’m guessing that it’s where I spent most of my growing up years?

Jeanne DininniNo Gravatar August 5, 2007

Thanks for the tag, Joanna! I seem to be getting a bit backed up on memes/group writing projects! Guess I’ll just have to get busy!

Jeanne

Jeanne DininniNo Gravatar August 5, 2007

It looks as if Laura is giving this project a great deal of thought! LOL!

Joanna YoungNo Gravatar August 5, 2007

Hi Laura

Well I took it as where I live now, I guess ‘cos it feels like home. The suburbs of London where I grew up many moons ago certainly don’t. I think you should interpret it however you choose - and whatever would be most fun or meaningful to you…

By the way for some reason I always seem to get multiple versions of your comments - often two, this time 4! Not sure if there’s something at your end?

Joanna

Yvonne RussellNo Gravatar August 5, 2007

Thanks for the glimpse into Edinburgh. I’ve only been there briefly. I can see I need to visit again.

Thanks for the tag. It may take a little while, but I’ll let you know when I’ve posted.

Joanna YoungNo Gravatar August 5, 2007

Hi Jeanne

You know I nearly didn’t tag anyone as it’s so easy to get into ‘debt’ and I didn’t want to add to the burden. I don’t know how the etiquette works really. The tags have a value in sharing links and saying ‘hello’. But it does seem a bit crazy if we end up thinking ‘oh no’ I’ve been tagged (I’m sure I’m not alone in that heart sinking thought…)

I for one would certainly never take offence if tagees (is this a word?) couldn’t or didn’t want to take part. I don’t like rules but if there is one it’d be only write as and when you want to, and have something to say:-)

Best wishes

Joanna

RobynNo Gravatar August 5, 2007

Joanna, I, like you, love the surroundings, especially when there’s a body of water! I’d love to come for a visit someday!

Brad ShorrNo Gravatar August 6, 2007

Hi Joanna, I really have to visit Scotland one day! Edinburgh sounds like a vibrant place, full of contrasts. Thanks for including me in this meme. Wonderful idea. It may take me a few days or longer to respond, because I’m transitioning my blog from Blogger to WordPress.

Robert HruzekNo Gravatar August 6, 2007

Joanna, what a wonderfully poetic description of a place I’ve always wanted to see for myself! Thanks for participating in my “World Tour”! Soon I’m going to start posting these and, if I can figure out how, I’ll include a world map so we can all follow along…

Cheers! :-)

Joanna YoungNo Gravatar August 6, 2007

Jeanne, apologies, in tidying up the duplicate comments (not sure what’s causing this) I somehow managed to delete your follow on comment:

“Joanna, Thanks for your graciousness! But, believe it or not, I’d already been thinking of taking part in this meme. Not only has Robert invited anyone who would like to participate in the meme to feel free to do so, but my (current) home town has one very fascinating–and somewhat quirky–tourist attraction that I plan to mention. You simply confirmed my feeling that I should take part! My only challenge–aside from finding the time to write the post–will be to make the meme fit my blog’s topic. (Perhaps I can pen a post about travel-related writing? Hmmm… I’ll have to give it some thought.) And, yes, I believe “tagee” is a word–though certainly not a common one! (At least it’s one that makes sense!) Jeanne”

I look forward to reading your contribution :-)
Joanna

Joanna YoungNo Gravatar August 6, 2007

Hi Robyn

I hope you manage a visit someday. I’m sure you’d enjoy it.

I agree with you that our surroundings matter a lot. Is this connected with our naturalistic intelligence I wonder?

Joanna

Joanna YoungNo Gravatar August 6, 2007

Brad, you’re right, Edinburgh is first and foremost a city of contrasts. It’s what makes it so appealing.

Some parts of the old town are literally on top of each other - one street crossing another way below. The ‘lower’ streets are/were often just that - darker, dirtier, poorer. I’m sure this is one of the reasons the city has inspired so many writers and so much literature.

I see you’re busy transposing WordSell - best wishes with the move and I hope there aren’t too many technical glitches.

Joanna

Joanna YoungNo Gravatar August 6, 2007

Robert, hi. It’s a great idea for a meme so thanks for kicking it off. I hope you can find a way to create the map too - it would be a great resource for us readers, writers, dreamers and travellers to dip into…

Joanna

Leave a comment

(required)

(required)